Partnership for Carbon Transparency publishes new guidance to enhance

When drilling into wood, especially cedar (like how I built these raised garden beds, below), it’s a good idea to drill a hole that’s a little bit smaller than the screw you’re using. This pilot hole allows the screw to go in more easily, while still having enough resistance. The pilot hole also protects the surrounding area. Cedar, for example, will crack and split if you try to drive in screws without a pilot hole.

This system of geologic and engineering analysis, supported by cross-functional teams involving drill-bit design engineers, drilling engineers, geologists, petrophysicists, geophysicists, and manufacturing personnel, has aided Chevron with many of its endeavors around the world including West Africa and Hibernia.

"The reason we picked our CAD program is because we can manipulate the program," he said, allowing in-house programmers to write additional code. Over the past 2 years alone, Lee said CAD systems have improved Hughes's ability to make changes fivefold.

This first of a two-part series describes the interacting relationships between CAD, CAM, and PDC drill-bit design activities, provided within the context of systems development. The conclusion provides an exclusive look into the flexible manufacturing process itself.

There are many philosophies in the industry as to what size cutters should be used for a particular formation. "Our belief is that for more abrasive, harder formations, you should use larger cutters because they wear slower. If they have more durability, they will last longer," Lee added. "And if there are more blades, you can place more cutters on the bit, allowing us to drill even harder formations."

Then, once the design is in place, the CAD file, stored on a network, becomes available to the shop floor where numerical coordinates provide instructions for the turning and milling operations.

And while masonry won’t split and crack without a pilot hole, good luck trying to get a screw to go in there. You’ll create a pilot hole the same way: use a masonry drilling bit that is smaller than the screw you’ll be using.

Whereas tungsten-carbide and steel-tooth bits crush and grind the rock, weight on bit (WOB) causes PDC cutters to indent the formation while rotation (torque) causes the cutters to shear the formation. Thus, each cutter is exposed to a specific torque and WOB force.

Eventually, cycle times may be reduced to the point where bits can be re-engineered, manufactured, and delivered to a wellsite on the same well, providing operators with a means to handle abruptly changing geologic environments as new information becomes available.

I laugh at myself now thinking about how nervous I was about driving into masonry. Now that I’ve done it, I’m thinking of other projects that I can use these masonry bits: adding a railing on my basement stairs (which requires me to drill into concrete, making a Welcome sign to hang on the brick wall near my front door, and more.

For example, Hughes Christensen tackles drilling-performance issues from three aspects: as individual components, as a drilling system, and as a manageable application where design-and-application teams apply extensive studies and research to improve the drilling process.

"Unfortunately, you cannot place as many cutters on the short profile as the long," Lee said, "so you must make compromises in the design to produce the optimal bit."

If you’re like me and you’re a newbie at drilling into concrete or brick, the easiest way to get comfortable with it is to practice. But before you can do that, you’ll want all of these materials on hand.

Have you ever needed to drill into concrete or brick? Well, if you own a house, I guarantee that there will come a day when you’ll need to–either to hang something over your masonry fireplace or to affix something to the outside of your brick veneer exterior.

As a result, the days when all the toolpusher had to do was look out his trailer door and select a bit from a line up, may soon be drawing to a close.

"So essentially what you are doing is placing one of these gauge pads in constant contact with the borehole, where one side of the bit constantly cuts and the other side constantly rubs." This creates a stable rotating condition.

For example, "Take a pen with a sharp point on one end and a flat cap holder on the other. The sharp end (long profile), when standing up, will fall down very easily. Thus, it becomes very unstable." On the other hand, the flattened cap end (short profile) has no trouble standing up.

"It used to be that everything in the manufacturing process was done by hand with manual equipment," he said. Nevertheless, over the last 10 years, the whole industry has made significant efforts to use CAD tools by adding direct data links to the shop floor.

That’s a good question. You’ll want to drill only as deep as you’ll need to for the screw to fit. Wood is a bit different in that you can drill 3/4 of the length of the screw. But with masonry screws, you’ll want to drill down the length of the screw.

After drilling the pilot hole in the brick veneer, I drove a masonry screw into the shutter and into the brick. It went in smoothly and tightened up nicely! Talk about feeling accomplished. It’s the little things, I tell ya. 🙂

"First we concentrate on providing best cutter technology, best product integrity, and design. Everything that involves the bit," Illerhaus said. For example, the development of polished cutters (Fig. 7), which provide the same coefficient of friction as ice-on-ice, has successfully reduced the specific energy needed to cut a formation.

The use of CAD, especially in directional PDC-bit design, has played an important role in tackling problems associated with whirl, a phenomenon recognized by Amoco 10 years ago in which the drill bit tends to spiral freely around the bit axis (Fig. 5). According to Lee, bit whirl, thought to affect wellbore rugosity, penetration rates, and bit longevity, can be controlled by stabilizing, or holding the drill bit up against the side of the hole.

Essentially, "Bit designers focus on improving the stability, aggressiveness, and durability of the drill bits," Lee said. "We have found a strong correlation between these factors."

Additionally, the operator simply did not feel comfortable providing the onsite supervisors total freedom to make bit selection, especially with some PDC bits costing up to $120,000.

As I mentioned before, typically you’ll want to use a hammer drill or an impact driver for drilling into brick or concrete. But if you’re like most homeowners, you’re most likely only going to own a regular power drill. Many tool brands will sell a regular power drill and an impact driver combo, keeping costs lower than if you bought them separately. Look for deals around the holidays to get a set!

As such, some companies, organized around business units with specific product lines, have begun to analyze the interacting relationships between drilling fluids, drill bits, and bottomhole assemblies, leading to the development of integrated product design across the corporation.

ALTHOUGH THE MANUFACTURING PROCESS IS OUT OF SIGHT and mind for the driller on the rig floor, developments in new technologies have actually pushed the supply-and-demand chain closer together, altering the decision-making process for bit selection.

"We've developed a work process with log and seismic data where we characterize the formation, along with the drilling data, to build a better bit," said Bill Calhoun, senior drilling engineer for Chevron Petroleum Technology Co. "But what really sets us apart is the ability to get very accurate data in the hands of the bit people in a timely manner."

You’ll notice my little test hole to the left. That’s the one that was a little too big. I drilled another hole in the brick, going smaller. The masonry screw had fit perfectly into the hole! Use a regular power drill with a driving bit to tighten it up.

With the introduction of the PDC bit in 1976, however, and substantial market penetration in the 1980s, this mode of bit selection could not be applied toward PDC bits. In effect, issues of factory-to-wellsite inventory relationships and design obsoleteness forced companies to closely examine and define drill-bit selection much earlier in the planning stage.

Secondly, the drill bits that you use for drilling into brick, stone, or concrete, would have to be masonry drill bits, like these concrete and brick masonry drill bits from Bosch called BlueGranite Turbo Carbide drill bits.

I grabbed a concrete paver from my garden to practice drilling into. If you don’t have one lying around, head to Home Depot and pick up a practice brick. They’re usually about $1 – $2. You’ll want to practice drilling into concrete or brick first before you try to drill into the concrete and brick around your home! At least if you “ruin” the brick, all is not lost. 😉 You’ll also want to make sure that the brick or concrete is secure. Use a clamp or a non-skid mat so when you’re drilling, the masonry isn’t wiggling and shifting.

Yet as these long strings of cuttings begin to amass in the hole, the mud-carrying capacity, which is a function of cutting size, begins to deteriorate, making it harder to suspend and bring the cuttings to the surface.

Then once the well or drilling program was over, the supervisor simply returned the unused bits to the supplier. This system of bit selection not only promoted competition among the bit manufacturers, leading to successive improvements in bearing and crushing structures, but led to the development of benchmarking studies aided by record keeping at the wellsite.

However, because it is a high-rpm bit, the cutters on the outside will wear at a faster rate as well. "So you may want more durable cutters on the outside also," Lee said. "Essentially, you can take the problem and break it into little pieces, approaching each problem with a solution."

Flexible manufacturing facilities, enabled by computer-assisted drafting and manufacturing (CAD, CAM) technologies, can now deliver custom-designed polycrystalline diamond compact (PDC) bits within 4-5 days, allowing operators to improve drilling performance in successive well activities.

"CAD is used in every step of the design phase," said Roger Lee, drill-bit engineer for Hughes Christensen. When engineers design a drill bit, the CAD system automatically lays out the cutters, fluid nozzles, blades, and junk slots (Fig. 1).

"The industry has done a lot of learning about tendencies, for example what drills good in shale and what doesn't. But we need to sit down and put numbers on how the bit will perform and how the formations will behave in a quantitative manner," Illerhaus said

Up until the late 1970s, bit selection was for the most part at the discretion of the toolpusher, driller, or company man. Armed with a large stock of steel-tooth or tungsten-carbide roller-cone bits, provided by a number of bit manufacturers, the onsite drilling supervisor could easily experiment with a variety of bits, well after well, until he found the optimum bit for a particular formation.

Lee said antiwhirl bits work well because this form of directed instability reduces bottomhole vibrations, inducing less strain on directional bottomhole assemblies, so that it becomes easier to steer and control the bit.

Our home has plastic shutters and one of the nails broke that was holding the shutter to the exterior brick veneer. The shutter was hanging by a single nail because of a wind storm, swinging horizontally in front of our window. (I’m sure the neighbors were curious why we let it hang there for nearly a week).

However, when drilling into concrete or brick, both the type of drill to use and the type of drill bit to use changes. Instead, you’d typically use a drill called a hammer drill. Not only does it spin the drill bit, allowing you to bore a hole into the masonry, but it has a hammering motion built in that allows the drill bit to dig in.

Although CAD provides an important tool for drill-bit design, producing an important link between information gathered in the field and the manufacturing process, engineers have found that drill-bit design forms only one segment of the drilling system. "It is important that a bit company today be actively engaged in looking at drilling systems as a whole rather than just the bit," Illerhaus said.

Masonry screws are usually blue. Although I knew what they were, I had never screwed into brick or concrete so I had never bought any until that shutter fell off the brick veneer of my home. I wasn’t sure what size to buy, so I bought both the 1-1/4″ and the 2″ masonry screws.

And, as silly as it sounds, I had felt so accomplished after driving my first masonry screw into this brick! HA! It tightened up securely. I knew that after successfully drilling into this brick, I was ready to tackle the hanging plastic shutter on my house.

Yet for Hughes Christensen, the change came about in 1986 when the company began to use numeric-controlled milling equipment with CAD software. "The most significant change in our industry is the automation of the design-and-manufacturing processes," said Roland Illerhaus, product manager of diamond drilling tools for Hughes Christensen.

I went slowly and carefully, testing out these BlueGranite masonry tips. This was literally my very first time ever drilling through brick! What had once seemed so daunting suddenly didn’t seem like such a big deal. There is always a first time for everything, right? 🙂

The profile, or blade curvature, directly affects these functions (Fig. 4). "If the profile is long, chances are it will have a hard time staying in balance when on bottom and drilling," Lee said.

What was surprising is that driving a screw into brick was just as easy as driving a screw into wood. It went in easily, without as much resistance as I assumed it would.

For example, a designer can eliminate all the cutters for Blades 3-7 then analyze fluid cleaning relationships between the nozzle flow and cutters on blades 1 and 2 (Fig. 2).

In tandem, these two views provide the engineer with the ability to model symmetry and visualize gaps and interactive attributes between the cutters and other bit components (Fig. 3). And because all the PDC components are provided in layers, the engineer can isolate and analyze relationships between nozzles, blades, cutters, and junk-slot depth.

For example, a 77/8-in. PDC bit may cost $30,000; whereas button and rock bits cost on the order of $6,000 and $4,000, respectively. Thus, the bit manufacturer could not afford to build up inventory at the factory, nor could the operator afford to hold large stocks on the wellsite.

If you’re doing a bigger job that will require a lot of drilling into concrete or brick, or thicker holes, definitely invest in a hammer drill to make the job easier and faster. I’m surprised that I don’t own a hammer drill already! I definitely plan on adding one to my collection soon!

On the other hand, the fundamental principles behind bit design continue to focus on the qualitative aspects, varying from engineer to engineer and company to company.

If you don’t have an impact driver, try drilling brick or concrete using a regular power drill. Although it’s not ideal, it can work, especially if you’re only boring one or two small holes.

As a result, however, this single modification has affected the cutting action of the bit, resulting in the production of cuttings that tend to peel off as long shavings (Fig. 8). Thus, engineers had to take a hard look at what effect increased cutter volumes would have on the drilling system as a whole.

To deal with the problem, the company developed a drilling fluid to disintegrate the cuttings, but not to the point where they ball up the bit. "The question now is, if the PDC cutters cut large cuttings, how small should we make them?"

Hubby, who also thought it would be too difficult to drill into the brick veneer, suggested (bless his heart) that we simply “glue it back” into place. As if gluing the shutter onto the broken nail sticking out of the brick would be a lasting solution. HA!Although drilling into masonry was something I had never done before, after getting my hands on a set of these Bosch BlueGranite hammer bits, when The Home Depot sent them to me to review, I realized that drilling into brick or concrete masonry is quite simple and didn’t require anything “fancy” in my toolbox other than the right bits and power tool. It’s nothing to be afraid of and certainly, nothing to avoid, as hubby and I had done!

Below, you’ll see my drilling a test hole into the brick, using a size that I thought would be perfect for the screw I am using. Later, I realized that I needed a smaller size drilling bit because the screw was too wiggly inside the hole.

If you know very little about drilling into masonry, the first question you might be asking is, “Can I use a regular drill to drill into concrete or brick?”

For example, Burlington Resources Inc. recently drilled a record 2,083-m, 121/4-in. PDC bit run in Algeria's MLC-2 well, located about 350 km from Hassi Messaoud.

And with bit costs affecting only 5% of a well's drilling investment but drill-bit performance affecting 80% of a well's costs, the possibility of just-in-time delivery may revolutionize the relationship between oil field operations and the factory (see box).

Whenever you drill a hole (typically into wood or drywall, if you’re a typical homeowner), there are two things you need: a drill and drill bits. A drill simply rotates the drill bit, and with a little force when pushing on the drill, the rotating drill bit will bore a hole into the wood, drywall, plastic, or whatever other materials you might be drilling.

If you’re using a regular drill, as I did, you’ll notice that you’ll need a bit of pressure on the drill. Start slowly. You’ll notice that the carbide tip will bore into the brick or concrete, pulling up masonry dust to clear the hole as you drill.

I’m Serena Appiah (rhymes with IKEA). I think home should be affordable. All you need is paint, power tools, and thrift stores.read more >

Thrift Diving inspires women to decorate, improve, and maintain their home themselves...using paint, power tools, and thrift stores! Use these 5 printables, checklists, and ebooks to get started!

The designer works with the CAD program in either 2D or 3D, mostly looking at the bit from two perspectives, top and side views. The program used by Hughes, developed on MicroStation (Bently Systems Inc.) software and operated in a workstation environment, contains layer upon layer of detail.

Additionally, because lateral vibrations can easily damage PDC cutters, as compared to tricone tungsten-carbide cutters or steel-tooth cutters, reduced vibrations also promote bit longevity.

"We actively work on whatever the bit is connected to-the drillstring, motors, stabilizers, shock subs, and drilling mud," Illerhaus said. For example, "We learned that the cuttings can be several feet long (Fig. 8). This was something totally new to us and the industry because mostly what you see at the surface are stubby little cuttings."

In a more comprehensive approach to drilling system design, the company may use a turnkey method. This involves multidisciplinary, knowledge-management teams that tie information from offset wells, drilling simulators (Fig. 9), research test facilities, and geophysical data with CAD and CAM technologies to design new drill bits and reconfigure bottomhole assemblies.

A good rule of thumb is to hold up the drilling bit and screw together you’ll be using and make sure that the screw is thicker than the drilling bit. Sometimes the screw packaging will tell you what size drilling bit to use. But if it doesn’t, holding them up so that they overlap, making sure that the drilling bit is a bit smaller will work. If necessary (and possible), do a test hole:

The combination of these two dynamic forces, which depend mainly on the location of the cutter, result in a net force of imbalance (Fig. 6). "Traditionally, the objective of a new bit design is to keep the imbalance force as low as possible," Lee said. Thus, to maintain stability, the bit must remain stable along the centerline.

Exactly what I was looking for. Thank you! Especially around which tool to use. Which bits to buy and that screwing something into concrete is possible! Thanks.

You’ll notice that I have tape on the BlueGranite masonry bit. The tape helps me to know how deep I need to drill and reminds me of when I need to stop drilling. (Don’t mind all the nasty spider wells and debris that was behind my shutter!).

In the end, the changing concept of drill-bit design, system integration, and information transfer may alter the way drilling operations are conducted in the future.

Experience, modeling, and common sense play a large role in drill-bit design. "From what we have learned, we can extrapolate. We can say that this new high-rpm application will turn a lot so you will probably end up with the gauge pads enduring wear." Thus, the designer will incorporate harder material on the gauge pad.

Although it's not a standard course of business, said Van Perrin, drilling engineer advisor for Chevron, when they "come up with ideas to cut faster hole, engineers can also take an existing design, mid-stream in the design-and-manufacturing process, and produce an improved PDC bit."

For example, "If you want a bit that is extremely aggressive, you might have to give up a little bit on stability." However, "If you have a bit that is stable, chances are that it will be durable as well."

"As we are completing the current well, we are already analyzing the data and designing a new bit for the next one," Calhoun said, "and this process can be continued well after well."

Yet even these considerations preclude the most important consideration-product life cycle. Rapid advancements in CAD, CAM, and flexible manufacturing technologies have shortened design-and-manufacturing times to the point where operators can now receive just-in-time, custom-designed bits. Thus, a particular PDC drill-bit design can quickly become obsolete, often in the same drilling program or on the next well.

I avoided drilling into brick and concrete for so long because it was one of those tasks that seemed like it would be “too difficult” or something that would require me to own a host of complicated tools. Recently, though, I couldn’t avoid it any longer.

"It is the first time in 15 wells, we drilled the entire interval with one bit run," said Lance Robinson, senior drilling engineer for Burlington. "Basically we gave the whole well to Hughes. We provided them with the lithology, bit runs, and offset data, and they did most of the work." And "With a fixed-price bit proposal, we incurred very little risk except to pay for the study."

To do this, designers adjust cutter orientation and back rakes, maintaining a low imbalance to make sure it drills on the centerline. With an antiwhirl bit, however, it is just the opposite.

The oil industry is not the first to implement flexible manufacturing systems, with Japanese automobile makers spearheading such developments in the 1970s. Today, flexible manufacturing processes have spread into many facets of everyday life with companies like Levi Strauss Co. producing tailor-made, skin-tight jeans from measurements taken at the point of sale.

Fig. 2 shows an example CAD "blue print" in which on the right-hand side (Top view), cutters are shown in red and blue while fluid nozzles are represented by circles with arrows. On the left-hand side (Side view), each of the cutters, as indicated by colored circles, correlates with the entire cutter assembly revolved on top of each other, encompassing all seven blades.

When I felt comfortable enough drilling into brick, it was time to drill into the brick veneer of my house. The previous nail was in the mortar, which was fine since the shutter wasn’t very heavy. But generally, drilling into the face of the brick is much stronger than drilling into the mortar. That is where I wanted to drill into.

"You actually want the bit to be imbalanced, and through tweaking we are able to control where that imbalance of force is applied," he said. In this case, the bit design embeds an imbalance against one of the gauges pads.