build-up, n. meanings, etymology and more - built up
There’s also an issue of potentially needing a different chipload if the rake in the ball is not aggressive enough to match the side flutes of the cutter.
To overcome these problems, special tool holders are required to minimize the chances of tap breakage during tapping. These are usually classified as conventional tool holders and CNC tool holders.
Solid dies cut a nominal thread form and depth, whose accuracy is subject to the precision the die was made with, and the effects of wear. Adjustable dies can be slightly compressed or expanded to provide some compensation for wear, or to achieve different classes of thread fit (class A, B and more rarely, C). Adjustable taps also exist but are not common. These have a tip that is split through the flutes and an axial screw which forces the cutting edges slightly apart.
Although in general machine tapping is more accurate, tapping operations have traditionally been very tricky to execute due to frequent tap breakage and inconsistent quality of tapping.
A comprehensive reference for US tap and drill bit sizes can be found in the chart provided by Albany County Fasteners. This chart includes detailed specifications for machine screw size, threads per inch, major and minor diameters, and appropriate drill sizes for different materials.
Taps and dies are tools used to create screw threads, which is called threading. Many are cutting tools; others are forming tools. A tap is used to cut or form the female portion of the mating pair (e.g. a nut). A die is used to cut or form the male portion of the mating pair (e.g. a bolt). The process of cutting or forming threads using a tap is called tapping, whereas the process using a die is called threading.
UPDATE: Tried it and it worked great. For example, one bit shows a feed rate of 54 ipm for hardwood, 90 ipm for softwood and 126 ipm for MDF/Laminate. The Amana database only has a default preset.
Double-lead taps and insert taps need different speeds and feeds, and different starting hole diameters than other taps.
I made a video about this to help explain chip load a bit better in simpler terms. The main take away should be that testing for bit temperatures is the key to getting the perfect chip load. Pause the project a few min into the cut and see how hot the bit is. I use a thermal heat gun to shoot my bit temps. Make adjustments until you have the coolest temps and that will be the best chip load possible. Link to the video. Beginners Guide To Feeds Speeds & Chiploads - YouTube
SFM to RPM
During the 19th and 20th centuries, thread standardization was evolving simultaneously with the techniques of thread generation, including taps and dies.
BTW, when you sign up for an account, the text I entered was white on a white background. Couldn’t see it at all. Should be a relatively easy change for you.
Thank you for bringing that to my attention… I did mess up where I said eighteen hundred rpm instead of 18,000. I need to add a note in that video about that correction. Its hard to give specifics because these numbers are different with every wood type and every bit size and depending on what time of year it is. !/4EM DC in pine was around 140deg F when dialed in while the upcut would run slightly cooler at around 120deg F. but that was in the fall when my shop was not really hot. I would usually take whatever temp it gives me and make small adjustments to see if there are changes or improvements looking for the lowest numbers. Over time you start to get a sense of what it sounds like and looks like when it is dialed in and you will be able to adjust it without the aids.
There’s also other machine variables like runout that add and subtract from chipload (feed/speed) in multi flute cutters. Resonance and CNC/tool rigidity would be 2 other quick examples that can’t be completely accounted for in most of the calculators.
In the same strain tool geometry will effect where your best cut will be as something like a tighter helix changes things like tear out chiploads, cutting forces, and what direction those forces are in.
A die cuts an external thread on cylindrical material, such as a rod, which creates a male threaded piece that functions like a bolt. Dies are generally made in two styles: solid and adjustable. An adjustable die may be adjusted either by an integrated screw or by a set of screws set in to the die holder (termed a "die stock"). Integral adjusting screws may be arranged to work axially, where the movement of the adjusting screw into a threaded hole in the die forces the slit section of the die open, or tangentially where a screw threaded in to one side of the slit bears against the opposite side of the slit. Dies without integrated screws are adjusted inside the die stock by radially-arranged screws. Two screws in the stock bear in to indentations on either side of the slit, tending to squeeze the slit closed, whilst a third screw with a tapered tip screws in to the slit forcing it open. Working these three screws against each other adjusts the die.
Tapping may either be achieved by a hand tapping by using a set of taps (first tap, second tap & final (finish) tap) or using a machine to do the tapping, such as a lathe, radial drilling machine, bench type drill machine, pillar type drill machine, vertical milling machines, HMCs, VMCs. Machine tapping is faster, and generally more accurate because human error is eliminated. Final tapping is achieved with single tap.
I used to be particular about chip load etc but after burning out three Makitas in a year decided to use setups that are easy on the router. I think that router bit longevity being shortened due to possible overheating is less expensive than replacing routers. So far have had no reason to change this after about 4 months of daily use. I also have one of these mounted on a bench lathe, but it would be simple to put it on a drill press or hand drill. which I use to clean each bit when I change bits. Very quick and very inexpensive. amazon.com/Jewelry-Polishing-Bristles-Polisher-Diameter/dp/B0B5QLVJT3/ref=sr_1_38?crid=U5OFE62M4Y4K&keywords=jewellers+bristle+brush&qid=1707684079&sprefix=jewellers+bristle+brush%2Caps%2C397&sr=8-38
There’s multiple issues with wood and correct chiploads (feed and speed). Since it’s a grown material it starts off variable and get more complicated from there. For a few common examples, woods cut differently with changes in grain structure, material integration, and moisture content. Some of those change it a lot like Rosewood or Ebony that integrates silica into the wood or very tight grained wood vs wide grain with the same hardness.
@cyberreefguru Hey Tom, I’ll give it a try. It’s $14.99 and I’ll provide a review here for all who may want to consider it. It looks like it could have good information and, hell, I stood here and asked for it.
i have some SPE bits and their website has a downloadable tool database that goes directly into fusion 360. pretty awesome. pick the tool, the type of wood and it presets all the numbers based on their manufacture recommendations. has worked really well. that doesn’t mean i haven’t edited some of the numbers but their numbers have worked 95% of the time without any changes.
To be clear, I don’t know what you’re cutting at, your tool geometries, or materials so you may be hitting a minimum chipload.
For the most part if you are using decent size and quality tools in soft material there’s a large range of “usable” chiploads. That’s not to say you can’t get better results digging into it but it’s more complicated than most assume. I feel it’s also worthwhile to learn a lot of these types of things to add to your troubleshooting and starting points. But not to the point of obsessing over the “optimal” vs cutting and making parts.
where T D {\displaystyle TD} is the tap drill size, M D {\displaystyle MD} is the major diameter of the tap (e.g., 10 mm for a M10×1.5 tap), and pitch is the pitch of the thread (1.5 mm in the case of a standard M10 tap) and so the correct drill size is 8.5 mm. This works for both fine and coarse pitches, and also produces an approximate 75% thread.
Be careful with these. There’s multiple issues but a quick summery would be that they are almost all making machine and material assumptions or giving conservative numbers. That not necessarily wrong, and to create a chart like this there’s not really a lot of options, it can lead to issues though. E.g. if they tested to get the numbers with an industrial machine those numbers will straight up break tools in a deflection limited system. The conservative ones, as long as they aren’t too conservative (rubbing) should be fine to use. You are probably leaving cut quality and tool life on the table but that may be worth the trade if you are doing one offs or short runs. Keep in mind that this will become less true as you get into larger tooling. There’s an assumption that as the tooling gets larger the machine gets more rigid. So you can get into areas where you’re machine limited even on the conservative numbers with larger tools.
where T D {\displaystyle TD} is the tap drill size, M D {\displaystyle MD} is the major diameter of the tap (e.g., 3⁄8 in for a 3⁄8-16 tap), and 1 / N {\displaystyle 1/N} is the thread pitch (1⁄16 inch in the case of a 3⁄8-16 tap). For a 3⁄8-16 tap, the above formula would produce 5⁄16, which is the correct tap drill diameter. The above formula ultimately results in an approximate 75% thread.
This functionally means that the only way to get “optimal” or the “best” settings is to test. Even big production shops with 6 figure machines do and only use calculators or manufacturer data as a starting point. I feel I should point out though that unless you are doing repeated cuts with the same tools and material or are on the margins of deflection/tool strength it may not be worth the time.
Usual preface, I’m with PreciseBits so while I try to only post general information take everything I say with the understanding that I have a bias.
Or is that a pipe dream? Maybe it’s not a calculator per say but a ‘multiplication factor’ of wood based on some standard.
I used to be particular about chip load etc but after burning out three Makitas in a year decided to use setups that are easy on the router. I think that router bit longevity being shortened due to possible overheating is less expensive than replacing routers.
There’s also the issue that any calculator to have better than a quick “start here” number would need to know more about the tool than most ask for. Millalyzer is better at this as it’s looking for tool geometry like rake and helix. However, most don’t and even Millalyzer is missing a lot of them. There’s also an issue of getting those numbers as most manufacturers rarely if ever give them out.
We created CNCExplorer for this purpose. Select bit and material and you can optimize your feeds and speeds (including depth of cut). We hope to have an iPhone app out in the near future, but the web app is available now. https://www.cncexplorer.com
Die nuts, also known as rethreading dies, are dies made for cleaning up damaged threads,[9] have no split for resizing and are made from a hexagonal bar so that a wrench may be used to turn them. The process of repairing damaged threads is referred to as "chasing." Rethreading dies cannot be used to cut new threads as they lack chip forming teeth.[10] However the external profile of a die does not strictly map to its function. Manufacturers of dies have produced models in a hex form which are intended for the creation of new threads.[11] These appear identical to solid dies in all aspects besides the external shape. Hexagonal thread cutting dies are used with a die stock with hexagonal holding features.
The biggest problem with simple hand-tapping is accurately aligning the tap with the hole so that they are coaxial—in other words, going in straight instead of on an angle. The operator must get this alignment close to ideal to produce good threads and not break the tap. The deeper the thread depth, the more pronounced the effect of the angular error. With a depth of 1 or 2 diameters, it matters little. With depths beyond 2 diameters, the error becomes too pronounced to ignore. Another fact about alignment is that the first thread cut or two establishes the direction that the rest of the threads will follow. You can't correct the angle after the first thread or two.
A tap cuts or forms a thread on the inside surface of a hole, creating a female surface that functions like a nut. The three taps in the image illustrate the basic types commonly used by most machinists:
Won’t go too much into this for bias reasons. However, I do like that they list chip thinning compensation for the listed stepovers. That will save a lot of people some headache.
Both tools can be used to clean up a thread, which is called chasing. However, using an ordinary tap or die to clean threads generally removes some material, which results in looser, weaker threads. Because of this, machinists generally clean threads with special taps and dies—called chasers—made for that purpose. Chasers are made of softer materials and don't cut new threads. However they still fit tighter than actual fasteners, and are fluted like regular taps and dies so debris can escape. Car mechanics, for example, use chasers on spark plug threads, to remove corrosion and carbon build-up.
Hi Jim - it’s free for 30 or 60 days – don’t recall which. That lets you evaluate it without committing. We can probably arrange a discount code too
In general, yes. This is due to most 3D work requiring stepovers of less than 10%. Any stepover that is less than 50% will have chip thinning which will make your actual chipload less than typically calculated. As an example let’s say that we are cutting with that 1/4" ball-nose (assuming a 2 flute) at 10KRPM with a 0.004" chipload. This would workout to 80IPM (RPM * Flutes * Chipload). However, let’s now say we are only using a 20% stepover. To cut that same 0.004" chipload we need to cut at 100IPM (1.25x). This gets worse the lower you go where 10% requires 133IPM (1.67X) and 8% where most will recommend a 3D finish pass is 147IPM (1.84x).
The largest tap and die company to exist in the United States was Greenfield Tap & Die (GTD) of Greenfield, Massachusetts. GTD was so vital to the Allied war effort from 1940–1945 that anti-aircraft guns were placed around its campus in anticipation of possible Axis air attack[citation needed]. The GTD brand is now a part of Widia Products Group.
To help with this alignment task, several kinds of jigs and fixtures can be used to provide the correct geometry (i.e., accurate coaxiality with the hole) without having to use freehand skill to approximate it:
Metalworking taps and dies were often made by their users during the 18th and 19th centuries (especially if the user was skilled in tool making), using such tools as lathes and files for the shaping, and the smithy for hardening and tempering. Thus builders of, for example, locomotives, firearms, or textile machinery were likely to make their own taps and dies. During the 19th century the machining industries evolved greatly, and the practice of buying taps and dies from suppliers specializing in them gradually supplanted most such in-house work. Joseph Clement was one such early vendor of taps and dies, starting in 1828.[1] With the introduction of more advanced milling practice in the 1860s and 1870s, tasks such as cutting a tap's flutes with a hand file became a thing of the past. In the early 20th century, thread-grinding practice went through significant evolution, further advancing the state of the art (and applied science) of cutting screw threads, including those of taps and dies.
While modern nuts and bolts are routinely made of metal, this was not the case in earlier ages, when woodworking tools were employed to fashion very large wooden bolts and nuts for use in winches, windmills, watermills, and flour mills of the Middle Ages; the ease of cutting and replacing wooden parts was balanced by the need to resist large amounts of torque, and bear up against ever heavier loads of weight. As the loads grew even heavier, bigger and stronger bolts were needed to resist breakage. Some nuts and bolts were measured by the foot or yard. This development eventually led to a complete replacement of wood parts with metal parts of an identical measure. When a wooden part broke, it usually snapped, ripped, or tore. With the splinters having been sanded off, the remaining parts were reassembled, encased in a makeshift mold of clay, and molten metal poured into the mold, so that an identical replacement could be made on the spot.
The work piece (blank) to be threaded, which is usually slightly smaller in diameter than the die's major diameter, is given a slight taper (chamfer) at the end that is to be threaded. This chamfer helps center the die on the blank and reduces the force required to start the thread cutting.[8] Once the die has started, it self-feeds. Periodic reversal of the die is often required to break the chip and prevent crowding.
Out of my own curiosity, have either of you measured the runout on these. There a few versions we’ve seen of these ER11 router and we can never seem to get any real data on them.
CNC Router with ER-11 collet opens you to a new world of router bits and End Mills not found in your hardware store router. Designed for M2, Maslow, and hobby CNC machines. Features 65mm diameter router, 12-foot (3.5-meter) power cable, 6-speed...
Whether manual or automatic, the processing of tapping begins with forming (usually by drilling) and slightly countersinking a hole to a diameter somewhat smaller than the tap's major diameter. The correct hole diameter is listed on a drill and tap size chart, a standard reference in many machine shops. The proper diameter for the drill is called the tap drill size. Without a tap drill chart, you can compute the correct tap drill diameter with:
Anybody spend the money to buy a Speeds & Feeds Calculator that takes the type of wood into account. There are such huge differences between the hardness of the different species that it wood seems to require one. There is one for sale on CNC Cookbook. Anyone have any experience with it?
The closest you can get to this is Janka rating and only for like grain structure and integration. It’s a hardness rating created by measuring the amount of force it takes to embed a steel ball to a certain depth in the wood. Again though that’s, only one part of the wood variability. It can be useful if you have good data in a similar wood. You can use it as a ratio to your chipload/feed or pass depth. Won’t be ideal but it will get you a starting number that’s decent IF your original is good.
The use of a suitable lubricant is essential with most tapping and threading operations. Recommended lubricants for some common materials are as follows:
I’m not aware of a good one. The closest you’ll get for less than the cost of a kidney is Millalyzer (Link) and it doesn’t have a lot of woods or a way of dealing with most of the below.
Quick question on this subject. do you use different settings when carving a 3D relief. As opposed to flatwork like a sign. an example is a 1/4 ballnose in maple.
Usually you can find recommended speeds and feeds for bits at the manufacturers website. Some even have tool databases of all their bits that you can import into your CAD/CAM software. I have tried CNC Cookbook in the past but now I just use the manufacturers recommendation and adjust it if needed.
Tappingspeed
@JDog Thanks for the excellent video. (One note: You kept saying “eighteen hundred RPM” instead of 18,000. But we know what you meant.). You don’t mention using a thermal heat gun in the video. That’s an infrared thermometer, I believe. What is the temperature range you’re seeing? What’s an ideal temp for a 1/4" two spiral upcut? (Just as an example.)
@Enginerd Chris, I’ve uploaded the Amana database and it’s a great place to start but it doesn’t take into account the type of wood.
@RockingMallet Hey Joshua, thanks for that link. What I like about it is that it takes into account the depth of cut and the stepover as well.
Unless there’s something I’m missing this doesn’t need to be an either or. Depending on where you are having issues (high RPM, or cutting force) you can change the cut to get both a decent chipload and something that the router can handle. e.g. Too much force cut the pass depth, too much RPM scale the RPM and feed.
Tapping case studies with typical examples of tapping operations in various environments are shown on source machinetoolaid.com [1]
With soft or average hardness materials, such as plastic, aluminum or mild steel, common practice is to use an intermediate (plug) tap to cut the threads. If the threads must extend to the bottom of a blind hole, the machinist uses an intermediate (plug) tap to cut threads until the point of the tap reaches bottom, and then switches to a bottoming tap to finish. The machinist must frequently eject chips to avoid jamming or breaking the tap. With hard materials, the machinist may start with a taper tap, whose less severe diameter transition reduces the torque required to cut threads. To threads to the bottom of a blind hole, the machinist follows the taper tap with an intermediate (plug) tap, and then a bottoming tap to finish.
Hope that’s useful. If anyone wants me to go more in depth on any of this let me know but I already am running into text wall territory.
While you can use heat as a sort of litmus test it’s not the most important part of hitting a minimum chipload. The real issue is that if you are not taking a large enough bite (chipload) you are not “cutting” but “rubbing” or “grinding” the material out of the way. Not only does this generate heat and reduce tool life but also increases the cutting forces (worse for the router) and produces a poor quality cut.
@RockingMallet Joshua, thanks for the heads up. Funny, because I’ve used SPE tools a lot; cheap and easy to get on Amazon (which I hate to use so much but I’m not a patient person and returns are so damn easy…).
18581906093