Walter to Buy Fellow Machining Supplier GWS Tool - solid carbide endmills suppliers

A discussion with Anna Marie Taylor, coeditor of the book and long-term partner of Lerner’s son, follows the excerpt.

Having withheld the details of the GE-Krupp conspiracy throughout most of the trial, the New York Times carried on its front page a story about the AEC action against the union. The court verdict against GE, on the other hand, was reported on the entertainment page alongside advertisements. It was the height of irony that the very union that was praised by civilian and military leaders for its outstanding role in helping the United States and its allies defeat Nazism was now the enemy.

Moving to milling and a miniature slitting cutter, Min-Slit, is claimed to be the smallest diameter indexable insert such tool available – 16-28 mm diameter with insert widths 2-3 mm, with those inserts having two cutting edges for greater economy. Employing special insert geometry and coolant directed to the insert, high productivity is possible. Fast insert change is again underlined. Multi-Master or Flexfit bodies are employed – no set-up time.

Lerner reports on suspect and frequently criminal activity against workers by major corporate entities and groups such as The American Legion, RCA and GE – why were these misdeeds so underreported?

Logiq-5-Grip, pushes this five-edge, solid insert system further on economy and performance. The current blade can employ existing 2-3 mm wide Tang-Grip inserts and can cut diameters up to 45 mm. Coolant directed at the cutting edge again features. But a new system is smaller, employing 0.8-1.6 mm wide Logiq-Slim inserts for parting diameters up to 22 mm – “The smallest width indexable insert for parting off and grooving.” When using 3 m bar and parting off components 10 mm in length, a 2 mm width insert will support production of 250 parts; 0.6 mm width inserts offer 283. Inserts are easily replaced with a simple tool in both cases – no set-up time.

The government introduced the following documented message from Krupp to GE: “Understand that you are offering carboloy for export to Russia stop We point out you are prohibited from doing so. Krupp.” When GE failed to satisfy its cartel partner, a harsher letter followed, concluding with an unspecified threat to GE (October 29, 1931). The threat had its desired effect, and in January, 1932, GE decided not to sell hard metal composition to The Amtorg Company, a Soviet purchasing agency. All this took place during the Great Depression when American workers were desperate for work. When Amtorg had advertised for 6,000 skilled American workers willing to take jobs in the Soviet Union, 100,000 people applied (Business Week, October 7, 1931).

And he hammers home the higher speed and feed message: “Today, the world is changing and today we are saying, go for higher feed rates, even when machining 60 HRc; forget the old times when you would run at low speed and feed, run at higher values, like woodworking. Change from large depths of cut to small depths of cut, because, if you go to 3D [printing], there is less to take off.” Harpaz points to face-milling at 3.5 mm per tooth as a possibility now; before it would have been 0.35 mm per tooth. And consider hard turning rather than grinding for materials of 50 HRc and up, he advises, stating that the surface finish will be “much better than grinding”.

Far from innuendos, the facts that appeared in UE News came directly out of the hearings of the Senate Patents Committee held in April 1942 after the government obtained the indictments. At those hearings, GE was accused of being responsible for a “drastic shortage” of an essential material needed for manufacturing tools in the United States. This, the senators found, was in contrast with the situation in Germany, where the Nazis had an abundance of tungsten carbide. It was at these Senate committee hearings that one of the defendants, William G. Robbins, president of the Carboloy Company, a GE subsidiary, leaped to his feet and exclaimed, “I refuse to be called un-American or that our company is un-American.”

ISCAR’s president revealed the company’s latest tooling developments to an audience of some 270 at Birmingham’s ICC in March. The main thoroughfares of the venue were decked with video screens and large hanging banners (cover image) to announce the event to those attending and passing through – these ISCAR (https://is.gd/tuhuno) undertakings are far from the usual product launch. And this was just one of a series of events on a world tour that Harpaz undertakes to spread the news of his company’s newest innovations, of which there are many.

Why be concerned about cutting tool innovation, though? Cutting tools represent just 3-4% of production costs. True, but they have a leveraging effect on other costs.

In 1933, when he was 22 years old, Jim joined a new organization called the American League Against War and Fascism and became one of its principal organizers. He traveled throughout the US and Canada to form local chapters of the League.

… a great deal of mystery has surrounded the production of this material since its inception. As a matter of fact, it is just about as complicated as making a good grade of concrete for a sidewalk. Grind up material, pass it through a mesh, put a certain percentage of binder with it, press it into a cake, and bake it.

What do you think James Lerner would think about the state of investigative and political reporting today?

After the war in 1947, I spent months covering the trial of U.S. v. General Electric Company, Fried, Krupp Aktiengesellschaft, E. T. I heard both the testimony presented by the government and GE’s defense arguments. The Krupp Corporation, whose offices were now temporarily under the control of the United States denazification authorities, was not called to testify. I told union members through a story in UE News:

The following excerpt is a particularly compelling account covering the GE-Krupp Conspiracy Trial in 1947. It details how GE and German manufacturer Krupp colluded during WWII to maintain a worldwide monopoly on the valuable war material tungsten carbide. It reveals the depth of GE’s Nazi past. Lerner was the only journalist to cover the trial in 1947. As Lerner told union members through a story in the UE News: “If you don’t see anything about the GE-Krupp cartel trial in your local newspaper, don’t be surprised. There’s no one at most sessions of the trial to report it. One day there were two commercial newspapers and UE News; the next day, one commercial newspaper and UE News. Today only UE News was left.”

Shortly before the tungsten carbide case had come to trial, the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) began what it described as an investigation into the fitness of UE to represent GE employees at the corporation’s Knolls Nuclear Energy Laboratory near Schenectady, New York. On the very week that Judge Knox was practically absolving the corporation of its conspiracy with the Nazi firm Krupp, the AEC directed GE to deny Knolls workers the right to be represented by UE. It claimed that the union presented a risk to the security of the United States. If this coincidence had been arranged in the corporation’s public relations department to discredit the union, the timing could not have been more perfect. (UE News, October 11, 1948).

Extra-long inserts for the Swisscut system are also pointed up. This range supports threading, parting, turning, back turning and groove turning. Parting off up to 20 mm, rather than the previous 7.5 mm is key, but also underlined is the ease with which inserts can be replaced. Two screws are loosened (not removed) and the insert withdrawn – zero set-up time.

Now, with a combination of both new toolholder (‘the hardware’) and insert (‘the software’), the Tang-F-Grip system that is only for high feed cutting sees that 25 seconds becomes 15 seconds. Although that’s for traditional X-axis direction parting; for Y-axis direction parting using the same insert, that is slashed again, to 10 seconds. Of course, coolant to the cutting edge is key. But that’s not the end of it; there is also a holder that will allow Y-axis benefits for X-axis parting that will deliver a cutting time of just 7.5 seconds.

I also love the last chapter, “Vietnam is Union Business” because it describes the courage that UE consistently showed to openly oppose the Vietnam War long before it was popular to do so.

In 1936, Jim was part of a US delegation of young people who attended the World Youth Conference in Geneva. He then clandestinely crossed over into Spain with a group who had been invited by fighters for the Spanish Republic to observe the front line against the Franco’s fascist army. As a journalist, he reported on the war for the US press and spoke at meetings and conferences held to support the Spanish Republic defenders.

When you came upon James Lerner’s manuscript, what kind of shape was it in? How did you pull together the narrative?

We have only 24 hours to raise $21,000 for Truthout. Independent journalism is a pillar of democracy, and we rely on your support to make our work possible. Please make a tax-deductible donation now.

Lest anyone imagine that corporate crimes being unreported by the mainstream media and punished with a wristslap are anything new, legendary labor reporter James Lerner’s account of the GE – Krupp conspiracy trial of 1947 is an eye-opener.

I was in the courtroom when a young man dressed in “army pinks” dragged in a heavy leather bag. For two days before being called to the witness stand, he guarded it carefully, even lugging it with him when he went to the men’s room. The bag, it turned out, contained 13 folders from the secret files of the Krupp firm at Essen, Germany. Here was the actual record of the conspiracy dovetailing the documents the government found in GE’s files. Company counsel had fought unsuccessfully to keep these records out of the trial. Charles H. Collison, chief of the metals section of the U.S. Office of Decartelization in Berlin, had previously informed the court that seven folders were missing. He told the court he believed these records were destroyed by the allied bombing of the Krupp Works.

After the opening days of the trial, I was also the only person in the courtroom who was not directly related in some way to the proceedings. I must have been conspicuous for my diligent presence, especially since I took extensive notes day after day. The defendants tended to ignore me even when I sat directly behind them to catch their comments. However, GE did not ignore what UE News would say about the case. Shortly before the trial was to begin, we ran a full-page story on the salient facts of the case based on the 160-page indictment. The company accused the union of printing “unproved charges of the indictments as facts” and of being antilabor because we were harming this great benefactor of the working man by printing such charges. This condemnation of UE News was distributed to all GE workers in the corporation’s own newsletter, Work News (February 7, 1947).

A brief item in UE News of September 7, 1940, a few weeks after I joined the paper’s staff, reported that two federal indictments were returned against the General Electric Corporation and the Krupp Armaments Works of Germany for conspiring to maintain a worldwide monopoly in production and sale of carboloy, a trade name for tungsten carbide. The government suspended its prosecution of the case at the outbreak of World War II. It was only seven years later at the war’s end, that I began to understand the full significance of these indictments.

X- and Y-axis turning innovation was underlined, with parting off in 100 mm diameter material now possible in 7.5 seconds

GE’s attempt to monopolize patent rights for tungsten carbide was undercut by a document found in its Schenectady files and presented as evidence. This consisted of a letter that was dropped into the company’s suggestion box at its Schenectady, New York, plant by W. L. Merrill, an engineer in charge of the production of tungsten carbide. Merrill proposed that the material be sold for $50 a pound instead of the $453 set by the company. He wrote in the letter:

ISCAR’s Pentacut, cost-effective five-edge single, ‘star-type’ insert system for grooving and parting has proved successful, but the company has introduced a system for smaller parts, called Pentacut Miniature Master, that uses a size 17 insert system (previous systems were 24 and 34). Insert widths are 0.25 to 3.18 mm. Coolant delivery above and below the insert again features. Swiss-type sliding-head machines are a key target.

So, in citing a part that takes 18 seconds to machine, a 30% discount on cutting tool costs gets you a 1% part cost reduction, doubling tool life gets you 1.5%, but increasing speed and improving the process can deliver a 15% cost reduction, Harpaz underlines – that is ‘machining intelligently’ with the new ‘Logiq Chess Line’ tools.

The mainstream media saw movements for change from the same perspective as the industrial corporations. Their coverage of peace and labor union organizing, court cases, etc. was therefore highly selective and clearly conformed to their own economic and political interests.

This mention of 3D printing is picked up more strongly, with the president highlighting that tooling will be getting smaller, due to the material volumes being removed shrinking, especially in turning – precision casting will similarly result in less material to remove, he notes. Smaller tools have the benefit of not requiring so much cobalt in their manufacture, a material whose price and availability are both being negatively hit by the demand for electric car batteries.

Masonry drill bit tip with a tungsten carbide insert brazed to the steel drill body. (Photo: Mendaliv / Wikimedia)Course of Action: A Journalist’s Account from Inside the American League Against War and Fascism and the United Electrical Workers Union (UE) 1933-1978 is a posthumous memoir of James Lerner, who was a prominent labor activist during World War II and until the 1970s. Course of Action, not published until September 26, 2012, details Lerner’s involvement as a youth organizer with the American League Against War and Fascism and his reporting about major strikes, the changes effected by the passage of the anti-union Taft-Hartley Act of 1947 and his role as managing editor of the UE News until his retirement in 1984.

Truthout is conducting a crucial fundraising campaign to support our work. We have 24 hours to raise $21,000.

Short set-up times, even zero set-up times, are another element in boosting productivity, and ISCAR has examples to offer in this area, too. For example, Multi-Master SolidMill solid carbide end-mills with replaceable tips that require no toolholder removal from the machine or presetting; also, the Swiss-Cut turning tool that can have its insert changed without the need to remove a screw – “it takes just a second to replace an insert”.

For deep parting and grooving in long overhang situations, a new holder having an anti-vibration feature counteracts vibrations – Whisperline. Offered with 5.5, 7.7 and 8 mm wide inserts, tool life is four times greater than the alternative, says Harpaz. Coolant delivery to the insert through the blade body again features.

What are your favorite chapters in the book? Is there a particular one you feel exemplifies his life and work particularly?

In March, 1948, General Lucius Clay, United States military governor in Germany after the war, ordered a halt to the decartelizing of Germany’s trusts. According to the New York Times, this had the effect of sparing “German industry any change in its corporate structure.” (March 13, 1948). The following spring, Charles H. Collison, Deputy Chief of the U.S. decartelization branch in Germany, who provided the Krupp files to the carboloy trial in New York City, was fired. He claimed that he was being punished for giving an army investigating committee proof of the failure of American officials in Germany to carry out the antitrust programs that had been agreed upon by the United States, Great Britain, and the Soviet Union following the war.

Jim was a modest, down-to-earth person. Despite the fact that his work required a lot of travel, he was basically a homebody. He loved his hobbies, which included carpentry, and photography and raising bromeliad plants. He was married to his wife Gertrude Fisher for 65 years and kept in frequent touch with his parents, children and extended family. Above all, he loved to tell stories.

Turning to new products, Harpaz offers some general themes that he gathers together under the banner ‘machining intelligently’, starting with attacking bottlenecks in milling, drilling, turning, grooving and parting off as the target for all the revealed developments. Of course, productivity can be boosted by investing in latest machine tools, but machines are not bought every day, so tooling can deliver through higher speeds and feeds. “Speed comes from the carbide grade and today ISCAR is offering very innovative grades, also taking in coatings, for any application,” the president underlines, adding later that large improvements are being gained via post-treatment of inserts.

Another area of development is in reducing the power/energy required to cut metal, which Harpaz refers to as ‘easy cut’. This also has the effect of prolonging tool life, he advises. An associated cutting by-product is vibration, another area where ISCAR has developed solutions.

In 1961, GE and Westinghouse and some of their officials were found guilty of conspiring to rig bids on the sale of turbines. Following the verdict, attorney Malcolm A. Hoffman, who had handled the government’s case in the tungsten carbide suit 11 years earlier and who had permitted me to examine the Krupp letters, wrote to the New York Times. He described how his request for jail sentences in the GE-Krupps tungsten carbide case had been rejected by Judge Knox. Hoffman noted that following that case, the United States subsequently brought 36 anti-trust suits against GE. In 1985, the corporation pleaded guilty to defrauding the government on missile-warhead contracts. This time, the court imposed a fine of $100,000 and $2 million in criminal and civil penalties.

Every single day, our team is reporting deeply on complex political issues: revealing wrongdoing in our so-called justice system, tracking global attacks on human rights, unmasking the money behind right-wing movements, and more. Your donation at this moment is critical, allowing us to do this core journalistic work.

Then, in 1982, an indexable system was developed that cut that to 1 minute 5 seconds. This was followed by the Tang Grip system, in 2004, that delivered 45 seconds, which was bettered by Jet Line insert toolholders having coolant delivery that reduced that to 35 seconds. Then, with the flat-top Tang-Grip-IQ blade, the current product, the time to part-off through 100 mm is 25 seconds.

The U.S. government charged that in 1938 the American and German firms agreed to divide up the world market for carboloy. Before the agreement, the product sold for $48 a pound in the United States. After the agreement, GE set the price at $453 a pound or one dollar per gram. The prosecution showed that under the agreement, Krupp would control the sale of carboloy everywhere in the world except the United States and Canada, which were GE’s turf. Government prosecutors refuted GE’s claim that its expertise and patents were the sole reason this valuable material was available to American industry. The government brought to the witness stand a parade of businessmen who testified that they had been producing and selling tungsten carbide before the GE-German agreement went into effect.

ISCAR is a €3 billion turnover metal cutting tool specialist, having notched up a record year in 2017, the president underscored ahead of the technical proceedings, adding that, based on Q1 figures, 2018 is anticipated as bettering that. ISCAR is part of IMC, which includes TaeguTec, Tungaloy and Ingersoll Cutting Tools. The IMC Group is the second largest company in the world for metalworking tools, comprising 13 companies. It has over 130 subsidiaries in 60 countries. ISCAR employs some 3,200 at its headquarters in Israel, with around 10% involved in R&D, into which the company sinks 4-5% of turnover. And 40% of turnover comes from products that are under five years old.

The company also offers the narrowest indexable insert slitting saw, Slim-Slit, a 32 mm diameter blade that holds inserts 0.6-1.2 mm wide (the Logiq-Slim insert mentioned previously) – performance is three times faster than a solid carbide slitting saw and 10 times that of HSS, Harpaz underlines. Fast, simple insert change and directed coolant delivery to flush out swarf via special shanks feature.

The evidence against GE became indisputable. As Judge Knox noted in his decision: “The defendants, by their counsel, have frankly admitted that they were monopolists and that they sought to prevent price competition.” He found the company guilty as charged. He then practically apologized for making the verdict and sentence by stressing that since the offenses of which GE was guilty were eight or nine years old, he personally had “a very strong indisposition not to punish stale crimes too severely.” The judge then turned down the government’s request that the defendants be given a six-month prison sentence. Judge Knox imposed fines totaling $56,000 against the corporation and the individual defendants. He stated that a failure to impose any punishment at all “would be misinterpreted by many people.” The government’s attorney, at one point, stated that the business community regards fines in antitrust cases as “a license fee, which may be charged off as part of the cost of doing business.”

In the winter of 1957, I sat in for several days at another trial involving GE. This trial was in the same federal courthouse where I sat through the GE-Krupp case many years before. Now every seat was taken and all the trial details were extensively reported in the tabloids, with photographs and drawings. GE officials were accused of transporting prostitutes from New York City to Newark, New Jersey, to entertain prospective GE customers. At UE News we decided to ignore the story. The sordid activities of individual corporate executives seemed insignificant next to the great crimes of corporate monopolies during the war that were flagrantly ignored by the media and public leaders.

I saw Jim’s drafts in many forms over a number of years. We used to all sit around the kitchen table in Brooklyn for hours on end, reviewing the ongoing writing and listening to Jim embellish stories for our benefit. Dick especially would often ask probing questions and make suggestions. Jim was very aware that the work needed more editing and gladly accepted when I decided to offer to work directly with him as a coeditor with Dick. During his lifetime, at his request, I was able to organize and edit some specific chapters that he wanted to give to family and colleagues. My goals in editing the manuscript became defined over time. They were to keep the narrative accurate, flowing and readable without changing the feel of Jim’s wry commentary and sense of humor. This meant eventually reorganizing some of the material into fewer chapters and adding a certain amount of transitional writing. It also required moving some very detailed material into notes and adding an index.

Other new introductions highlighted were: Jet-R-Turn/Jet Master rigid toolholders offering coolant channels for standard and high pressure coolant delivery from above and below the insert, three coolant inlet positions and easy insert changing; Logiq-4-Turn, economical double-sided 80° positive inserts for alloy steel, plus toolholders that deliver coolant to the cutting edge; Alu-P-Turn 35° and 80° inserts for aluminium that boast four cutting edges and 9 mm cut depth, not 12 mm, for economy (re the earlier cobalt cost comment), for use with existing Flashturn holders; Whisperline anti-vibration boring heads, recommended for 7-10xD; Nanmill 8 and 10 mm diameter indexable insert end-mills with two and three cutting edges respectively, offering 3 mm depth of cut and fast insert change; Heli-3-Mill 90° corner insert system now in diameters 10, 12 and 16 mm; Tangfin face-mills for micron-level surface finishing with tangentially-clamped inserts having four cutting edges, 50-160 mm diameter; and Logiq-8-Tang face-mill with inserts having eight cutting edges (four before), 40-125 mm diameter. ■

Krupp was one of the German companies that notoriously financed Hitler’s political career when he pledged to crush the labor movement before launching his drive across Europe. I was aware from trial evidence that even before Hitler came to power in 1933, Krupp had made its sympathies known with its “Heil Hitler” letters. Another letter from GE to a prospective customer, found in the files of both companies, dated April 18, 1940, read: “We are not permitted to sell tungsten carbide to China; you’ll have to take your business to Germany.” Rather than promoting employment as claimed at the trial, the cartel was in fact giving away American job opportunities to foreign workers.

General Electric defendants were visibly shaken when the witness opened the lock on his leather bag and began pulling out file folders. U.S. Attorney Malcolm A. Hoffman, who was in charge of the government’s case, let me examine those documents in his office several floors above the courtroom. The memory of the war’s horrors was still vivid in my mind as I read letter after letter from Krupp to GE officials ending with the phrase “Heil Hitler.” I thought of concentration camp scenes that Allied armies had found in Germany, of the millions of people, including my own relatives, who disappeared forever into Hitler’s death camps. By this time, the world knew that Krupp had run some of the camps where slave laborers produced goods for Nazi armies. In defense of its arrangements with Krupp, GE claimed that its tungsten carbide deal helped create jobs for American workers. Evidence showed, however, that the cartel arrangement actually resulted in job losses.

This book is important if it is true that we can learn from our history. It is especially valuable because Jim documents how on-the-ground, persistent and fearless commitment by broad-based movements for social justice matter during times of great political change and conflict. Jim conveys this history with personal stories of everyday, often behind-the-scenes events. This history still has meaning today for social justice movements in the age of Occupy, Google, Facebook and Twitter.

Jim had the gift of crafting broad coalitions of people into the anti-war movement before the outbreak of World War II. This included bringing into one movement national organizations of all kinds, including political and religious organizations, student and youth groups, farm organizations and pacifists, who felt it was important to work in antiwar coalitions even though their philosophies differed.

Anna Marie Taylor: James Lerner, the author of this book, is the father of my partner of more than 30 years, Richard Lerner. We frequently traveled from California to Brooklyn, New York, to visit his parents, and I got to know them well. After Jim retired in his early 70’s, Richard encouraged him to write his memoir because of his involvement in some of the most critical events of the 20th century. These included the antifascist movement in the United States, of which little has been written, and the surge of the industrial labor movement during and after World War II.

“One of the government witnesses at the trial explained how a tool edged with tungsten carbide could be used 1,000 times before it had to be reground compared to only 100 operations using other tools. The indictment also cited tungsten carbide’s superiority in parts for lathes, drills, saws, and other devices used in the production of military equipment and automobiles.

Truthout doesn’t take corporate funding – this lets us do the brave, independent reporting that makes us unique. Please support this work by making a tax-deductible donation today – just click here to donate.

Merrill went on to suggest that since the current actual cost of producing the product was $8 a pound it could be sold at his suggested price of $50 a pound, and still “give us approximately a 7 to 1 markup over manufacturing cost which should be a satisfactory profit.” It started to become clear at the trial that while the company was boasting of its great patriotic service to the nation, it was charging an exorbitant markup for a strategic war material.

Jim never thought of himself as “objective” in the sense of purporting to present all sides of an issue. He considered himself a labor journalist, whose job it was to truthfully provide and analyze local, national and international news in a way that would be relevant to working people and that would advance their welfare.

Every five years, or so, tooling giant ISCAR unveils a major package of developments, revealed via a number of global roadshows fronted by company president Jacob Harpaz. Andrew Allcock was in the audience and reports on the company’s latest innovations

A further key theme is chip evacuation: “If you solve the problem of chip evacuation, you can go to much higher feeds,” he offers, adding that surface finish is also improved. And chip evacuation is achieved via coolant delivered directly to the cutting edge, a feature of many of the new products.

Innovation that builds on Pentacut, Logic-5-Grip. The existing blade (left) can employ existing 2-3 mm wide Tang-Grip inserts and can cut diameters up to 45 mm. A new smaller system (right) uses 0.6-1.6 mm wide Logiq-Slim inserts for parting diameters up to 22 mm wide

Turning first to Grip systems for parting and grooving, he says that while others also can offer double-ended parting inserts, ISCAR’s system has the capability to allow for depths that exceed the insert length, due to its twisted Do-Grip insert design that protects the reverse end. While still retaining the same insert, which can cut through 100 mm in 35 seconds, by delivering coolant through the holder (JHP style) from above and below the insert cutting edge to improve chip evacuation, that 35 seconds becomes 25 seconds, with no need to use high pressure coolant, unless cutting challenging aerospace materials. Other inserts are available that have coolant delivery holes in them, further aiding chip evacuation.

Jim was one of the original students at the Experimental College at The University of Wisconsin, Madison. The college was known for its innovative teaching model.

Moving to single-ended inserts for parting off, in 1978, 100 mm took four minutes, using brazed tip tools, but ISCAR developed a system that had a chip breaker and that cut the time to 1 minute 30 seconds.

For me personally, my favorite chapter is “I Cover the GE-Krupp Conspiracy Trial.” because it reveals an important trial in US History that was ignored by the mainstream press and whose lessons of profit over national security should never be lost.

Journalists supposedly try to be objective in their reporting – yet Lerner has a genuine political affinity with much of his subject matter. What do you think he would say about this issue?

At UE News, Jim began by reporting on stories of interest to union members, often reporting on-the-ground at work actions and strikes or writing about people’s everyday lives. Jim also started the pithy and often humorous column called “It Happened This Way” that ran from 1948 to 1986. The column became well known for its barbs at corporate actions and misdeeds that affected workers.

How did GE influence the press? One day at the carboloy trial, I saw defendant William G. Robbins reach into his pocket for his wallet and remove a clipping that he passed around to other defendants with obvious pleasure. Leaning forward, I could see that the clipping dealt with the indictment of Carl Marzani, who had made a film for UE called Deadline for Action (1946). The film offered an exposé of monopoly practices, including the tungsten carbide conspiracy. Marzani was tried and convicted on charges that he denied being a member of the Communist Party and had falsely signed a loyalty statement. He served 34 months in federal prison.

He would have been encouraged by the proliferation of progressive news sources and the international access to communication that is now available to people all over the world through the internet. He would have thought that it would especially be of immeasurable value to youth activists, something close to his heart. He would have compared its effectiveness, often instantaneous, to how he traveled by ground from place to place as a young man, lucky to have access to a telephone.

Trial testimony showed that smaller competitors were either driven out of business or forced to go along with the price set by the monopoly. Methods used to accomplish this, according to witnesses, such as the president of the Union Wire Die Company, included forced buy-out of competitors. The head of American Cutting Alloys testified that he begged GE not to drive him out of business.

If you don’t see anything about the GE-Krupp cartel trial in your local newspaper, don’t be surprised. There’s no one at most sessions of the trial to report it. One day there were two commercial newspapers and UE News; the next day, one commercial newspaper and UE News. Today only UE News was left.I thereby sat there as the only reporter remaining to hear the full story of the partnership between GE and Krupp, its German partner. I could not help thinking what a field day the press would have had if union leaders were under criminal indictment instead of corporations.